1872-1874: C.W. Ingersoll

1874: W. C. Brown

1875-1878: Jas. G. Weakley

1878, 1879, 1880: No Record

1881-1885: W. H. Dewey

1885: W. H. Fox

1887-1891: James E. Smith

1891: F. S. Rockefeller

1893-1897: A. W. Kenyon

1897-1900: F. W. Vanderbur

1900-1902: No Record

1902: Charles Hoopman

1904-1908: John G. Banker

1908-1912: John G. Bogan

1912-1916: John G. Banker

1916-1920: P. A. Peterson

1920-1924: W. H. Sellens

1924-1928: P. A. Peterson

1928-1932: W. H. Sellens

1932-1936: Roy S. Thoman

1936-1938: Harry J. Reiff

1938-1942: Ted Steinle

1942-1946: Russell Clark

1946-1948: Ted Steinle

1948-1950: Francis E. Goodman

1950-1954: Milton Galyardt

1954-1958: Harry L. Morgenstern

1958-1962: Milton Galyardt

1962-1970: Jule Dumler

1970-1976: Milton Galyardt

Elected every 4 years

1976-1980: Larry Batt

1980-1984: Gary Clark

1984-1988: Tom Keys

1988: Tom Keys Resigned - Robert Balloun Appointed by Governor

1990-1994: Robert Balloun

1994: Robert Balloun Resigned (retired) - Tim Holmes Appointed by Governor

1996: Tim Holmes

1999: Tim Holmes Resigned - John R. Fletcher Appointed by Governor

2000-2004: John R. Fletcher

2004 to present: John R. Fletcher

Sheriff John R. Fletcher